Arrests of Tornado Cash developers fueled an outbreak of criticism among blockchain and cryptocurrency opinion leaders. However, some investors claim it was a necessary victim for institutional adoption.
On August 12, Dutch Fiscal Information and Investigation Service (FIOD) said in a statement that they arrested a 29-year-old individual in Amsterdam suspected of involvement in concealing criminal financial flows and facilitating money laundering" via Tornado Cash. The Block revealed that the individual was Alexey Pertsev, Tornado Cash co-founder and engineer, citing his wife confirmation. Furthermore, CoinTelegraph reported citing its own sources that two other founders of Tornado Cash, Roman Panchenko and Nikita Dementyev, were arrested, as well, in Seattle and Tallinn, respectively.
The arrests came after the United States Treasury Department had put multiple Tornado Cash addresses on the sanctions list of the Office of Foreign Asset Control (OFAC) on August 8 due to billions of dollars, including funds stolen by North Korean hacking groups, found laundered via the service.
This step caused a wave of outrage among crpto communit leaders. Co-founder and CEO at Coinbase Brian Armstrong called it "a bad precedent" that could have "unintended consequences".
Sanctioning a technology (as opposed to an individual or entity) seems like a bad precedent to me, and it should probably be challenged. Could have many downstream unintended consequences.#TornadoCash
— Brian Armstrong - barmstrong.eth (@brian_armstrong) August 14, 2022
Hopefully obvious point: we will always follow the law.
Chris Burniske, a cofounder of Placeholder, a New York-based venture firm that specializes in cryptoassets, ironically noted that Tornado Cash is a tool, and it can't be considered bad or good on its own.
Bad people use words, words are bad
— Chris Burniske (@cburniske) August 13, 2022
Bad people use H2O, H2O is bad
Bad people use flour, flour is bad
Bad people use cars, cars are bad
Bad people use cash, cash is bad
Bad people use crypto, crypto is bad pic.twitter.com/zDsTWjbW1c
As an act of protest, an anonymous user sent small amounts of Ethereum to well-known individuals in the cryptocurrency community from the OFAC-blocked Tornado Cash service. The list of recipients included many US residents, such as artist Beeple, Coinbase CEO Brian Armstrong, Randy Zuckerberg, and others. Following these transactions, Aave DeFi protocol blocked TRON founder Justin Sun's wallet and a number of other users from accessing the platform as they all received 0.1 ETH from an anonymous user.
I’m officially blocked by @AaveAave since someone sent 0.1 eth randomly from @TornadoCash to me. @StaniKulechov pic.twitter.com/tNXNLNYZha
— H.E. Justin Sun🌞🇬🇩 (@justinsuntron) August 13, 2022
Later, the Aave team clarified that they use TRM's tools to automatically identify and block black-listed addresses. Being aware of the "dust attack", Aave developers fixed the problem.
"We have been made aware that the API may have made incorrect calls about which wallet should be included in block-lists, in this case including those wallets that were sent “dusted” ETH by third parties interacting with the Tornado Cash contracts without consent."
4/8 We have been made aware that the API may have made incorrect calls about which wallet should be included in block-lists, in this case including those wallets that were sent “dusted” ETH by third parties interacting with the Tornado Cash contracts without consent.
— Aave (@AaveAave) August 13, 2022
The ban also provoked discussions on whether it is possible to achieve transaction privacy and possible solutions of this problem. Jackson Palmer, Dogecoin creator, suggested that the transaction privacy should not be reached by mixing one's funds up with other's coins.
The solution to transaction privacy is doing it at the core protocol level - not mixing your funds up with various other unknown actors on a Layer 2 service.
— Jackson Palmer (@ummjackson) August 13, 2022
You can absolutely defend the importance of privacy without dying on some weird hill for the latter.